The Organic Gardeners Forum

You are not logged in.

Announcement

New registrations have been temporarily disabled

#1 27-May-2007 7:44 am

DAR
Member
Registered: 30-July-2006
Posts: 10

Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

What is the difference between horticultural oil and neem?  What is the use for each product, and can either of these be used to treat a fungal problem with groundcover such as pachysandra?

Offline

 

#2 27-May-2007 10:42 am

mrs.knowitall
Member
Registered: 19-October-2005
Posts: 943

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Horticultural oil is just what it says it is, an oil.  It is used to smother insect eggs and scales before they hatch or move on to other parts of the plant.  There is a dormant oil, used before bud swell/break and a summer weight oil which must be timed properly and used on plants that are not stressed and well watered.  Follow the directions on the labels because while it is safe, if used improperly, it can burn your plant. 
   Neem is derived from the Neem plant ( Azadirachta indica) and is an insecticide.  It is used to kill insects.  You will see it called Neem, Azatin, Margosan on the label.  While it is a naturally occuring product, you still must use caution with it such as gloves and eye protection.  Depending on the formulation, it does have some residual activity as well as being able to drench with it but here again,  you must read the label carefully. 
   If you have a fungal problem on your pachysandra, you should first identify the problem before treating it.  Neem has been touted as a fungicide for a few problem but is very limited in it's scope.


"We are quicksilver, a fleeting shadow, a distant sound. Our home has no boundaries beyond which we cannot pass-we live in music-in a flash of color. We live on the wind and in the sparkle of a star."

Offline

 

#3 27-May-2007 5:00 pm

DAR
Member
Registered: 30-July-2006
Posts: 10

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Mrs. Knowitall - Thanks for your reply.  I believe that it is a fungal problem (volutella pachysandrae) based upon a description and pictures that I found on the Internet.

Offline

 

#4 29-May-2007 7:26 am

GardenGal
Member
Registered: 03-January-2007
Posts: 1082

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Denise,
Can you recommend a product for spraying on my ornamentals that get lacebugs. I get it bad on my pieris japonica and some of my azaleas even though they are in a shaded area. Is it better to use neem or a light horticultural oil? And if the oil, what would be a brand I am looking for?


The Non-Conforming Gardener
"Just because everyone is doing it, does not necessarily make it right."

Offline

 

#5 29-May-2007 1:12 pm

jess
Administrator
Registered: 10-July-2005
Posts: 778

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

I'm not Denise, but I can answer.  Neem or horticultural oil would work fine.  I personally would use the oil, but make sure you fully saturate the tops and undersides of all the leaves and then repeat the application about 14-21 days later.  I use SunSpray brand.

Jess

Offline

 

#6 30-May-2007 9:37 am

GardenGal
Member
Registered: 03-January-2007
Posts: 1082

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Thanks Jess. I will give it a try.


The Non-Conforming Gardener
"Just because everyone is doing it, does not necessarily make it right."

Offline

 

#7 30-May-2007 2:46 pm

mrs.knowitall
Member
Registered: 19-October-2005
Posts: 943

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Garden Gal,
         I like the Sunspray oil myself but if you are getting lacebugs on your pieris, you may want to consider moving it to a shadier locations.  Usually you see lacebug when a plant is stressed by being in too much sun or too dry.


"We are quicksilver, a fleeting shadow, a distant sound. Our home has no boundaries beyond which we cannot pass-we live in music-in a flash of color. We live on the wind and in the sparkle of a star."

Offline

 

#8 31-May-2007 7:40 am

GardenGal
Member
Registered: 03-January-2007
Posts: 1082

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Can I buy SunSpray locally? I looked at several nurseries and could not find it. Do either of you order it from some online company or get it at location in our area.   I think that my pieris is too dry. It is getting shade but it gets dry where it is located. Although I have been adding more leave compost and that area is retaining more moisture. I will spray and if that does not work,  I will move it to a more northern and shady location.


The Non-Conforming Gardener
"Just because everyone is doing it, does not necessarily make it right."

Offline

 

#9 31-May-2007 7:08 pm

mrs.knowitall
Member
Registered: 19-October-2005
Posts: 943

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Char,
     Try to water more often...I know, it's this heat.  Sunspray is a Safer product I believe so you may want to check their website and look for a store locator.
denise


"We are quicksilver, a fleeting shadow, a distant sound. Our home has no boundaries beyond which we cannot pass-we live in music-in a flash of color. We live on the wind and in the sparkle of a star."

Offline

 

#10 01-June-2007 11:06 pm

GardenGal
Member
Registered: 03-January-2007
Posts: 1082

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Thanks Mrs. K. I will water more often. One of my plants is actually doing much better this year. I think the ammended soil is helping alot.


The Non-Conforming Gardener
"Just because everyone is doing it, does not necessarily make it right."

Offline

 

#11 27-March-2008 8:37 am

joy
Moderator
From: Squirrel Hill
Registered: 21-June-2006
Posts: 1137

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

I applied dormant oil to my pear trees a few days ago, and today it's raining.  I'm sure it'll all wash off in the rain.  How long does it take for the oil to work? Yesterday when I looked at my trees, there was one branch (up high on one of them) that was started to break bud, but the others are still in bud.  I know we don't want to apply dormant oil after the buds break because it will stress the tree.  Should I then, after it rains, apply the SunSpray that you talked about earlier in this thread? 

Also, what is your opinion about using a home-made vegetable oil spray instead of the commercial spray?  I saw a recipe at http://www.care2.com/greenliving/a-less … t-oil.html that called for:

1 c vegetable oil
2 T liquid soap
1 gallon water

It didn't specify what type of vegetable oil? corn? olive? canola? Does it matter?

Thanks,
Joy

Offline

 

#12 27-March-2008 10:15 am

mrs.knowitall
Member
Registered: 19-October-2005
Posts: 943

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Joy,
      Do not use that recipe.  It's a waste of your money when you can use something specifically formulated for plants, not a salad. I don't think you would want to ruin your plants just to save a few cents. You are also like to attract some unwanted visitors to your tree with that mix.  The dormant oil should be fine on your trees if you applied it a few days ago although I'm a little concerned because you do have some buds breaking.  I wouldn't apply the Sunspray oil so soon after applying dormant oil.  I think you will be fine as is.
denise


"We are quicksilver, a fleeting shadow, a distant sound. Our home has no boundaries beyond which we cannot pass-we live in music-in a flash of color. We live on the wind and in the sparkle of a star."

Offline

 

#13 27-March-2008 10:50 am

joy
Moderator
From: Squirrel Hill
Registered: 21-June-2006
Posts: 1137

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

The buds weren't breaking when I applied it, but they are now.  Only on one branch, but Spring is springing!

Thanks for the recommendation, I'll leave my salad oil for my salads!

Joy

Offline

 

#14 30-March-2008 12:06 pm

gnosticgardener
Member
From: Grove City/Slippery Rock
Registered: 05-November-2005
Posts: 1318
Website

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Do y'all know an easy way to spray the undersides of leaves?? I wish I could turn all my plants upside down!


Freelance Writer
Gardening Columnist

Offline

 

#15 30-March-2008 9:26 pm

mrs.knowitall
Member
Registered: 19-October-2005
Posts: 943

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Turn your arm downside up :-)


"We are quicksilver, a fleeting shadow, a distant sound. Our home has no boundaries beyond which we cannot pass-we live in music-in a flash of color. We live on the wind and in the sparkle of a star."

Offline

 

#16 01-April-2008 1:27 pm

blackthumb
Member
From: Greenfield
Registered: 02-April-2007
Posts: 47

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

watch out for the neem.  a little bit goes a long way.  and don't let it get on your skin.  or in your eyes.  and make after you use it to wash your hands BEFORE going to the bathroom.

Offline

 

#17 01-April-2008 9:46 pm

mrs.knowitall
Member
Registered: 19-October-2005
Posts: 943

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Blackthumb,
        While I was making a joke you are correct about not getting it on your skin or in your eyes.  If you are spraying anthing at all, minimum should be long sleeves, gloves and protective eye wear of some kind.  Just because it's organic or natural, it is still designed to kill something.


"We are quicksilver, a fleeting shadow, a distant sound. Our home has no boundaries beyond which we cannot pass-we live in music-in a flash of color. We live on the wind and in the sparkle of a star."

Offline

 

#18 12-January-2009 11:50 pm

Viridissima
New member
Registered: 12-January-2009
Posts: 3

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

This discussion has been helpful in my understanding of the difference between hort. oil & neem.  Thank you all for you helpful input.  Although, I am still searching for a thorough explanation of the difference between hort. oil & safer soap.  Any thoughts...?

Offline

 

#19 13-January-2009 6:57 am

gnosticgardener
Member
From: Grove City/Slippery Rock
Registered: 05-November-2005
Posts: 1318
Website

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

I must be superman, not that I don't use caution when I'm mixing or using neem spray, but I've gotten overspray on my skin more than once without any ill effects.

As for the difference between hort oil and safer soap Viridissima, I'll defer to the experts.


Freelance Writer
Gardening Columnist

Offline

 

#20 13-January-2009 1:44 pm

doster
Administrator
Registered: 05-July-2005
Posts: 2276
Website

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Horticultural oil is just that, an oil that coats the plant and more importantly offending pests, smothering them. Insecticidal soap is different product and work a little differently. The soaps kill susceptible insects by washing away the protective coating on the surface of the pest and by disrupting normal membrane functions inside the insect. Just like horticultural oil the soap must come in direct contact with the insect.

Offline

 

#21 14-January-2009 12:12 pm

Viridissima
New member
Registered: 12-January-2009
Posts: 3

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Thanks doster!

Offline

 

#22 10-October-2009 2:26 am

leannehammer
New member
Registered: 10-October-2009
Posts: 1

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Well, how long till i can spray them then?

Offline

 

#23 10-October-2009 8:37 am

gnosticgardener
Member
From: Grove City/Slippery Rock
Registered: 05-November-2005
Posts: 1318
Website

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

jess wrote:

...make sure you fully saturate the tops and undersides of all the leaves...

That's impossible.


Freelance Writer
Gardening Columnist

Offline

 

#24 10-October-2009 10:05 am

wldrnss
Member
Registered: 16-April-2006
Posts: 625

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

Did someone suggest a horticultural oil that could be used year round?  Was it the Sunspray?  It seems as though I remember that, but you know how memories go.

Offline

 

#25 10-October-2009 6:41 pm

doster
Administrator
Registered: 05-July-2005
Posts: 2276
Website

Re: Horticultural Oil vs. Neem

gnosticgardener wrote:

jess wrote:

...make sure you fully saturate the tops and undersides of all the leaves...

That's impossible.

Why?

Offline

 

Board footer

Powered by PunBB
© Copyright 2002–2005 Rickard Andersson

[ Generated in 0.093 seconds, 6 queries executed ]